1 year post upper eyelid surgery - was enough skin removed? (photo)

Thank you for sharing your photo and questions. To get further improvement you would require an endoscopic forehead lift and (possibly/likely) addition skin removal from the upper eyelids. While the brow lift would be subtle, it is unlikely you'd get satisfactory results from upper blepharoplasty alone. Your primary surgeon was exercising good judgement in not offering additional surgery and being conservative.

It is not uncommon for different surgeons to have varying opinions. When performing an upper blepharoplasty it is important to take enough skin but not too much. Typically patients are looking for a nice improvement that looks natural. As we say in my practice- You. Only Better. If you have concerns there is not harm in seeking various opinions from a few board certified plastic surgeons near you.