Do I have alar retraction, columella hanging or combination of both? (photos)

It appears that you have both a hanging columella and alar retraction. The hanging columella is much more prominent than the alar retraction. Alar Retraction is  treated with composite skin grafts harvested from the ear, while a columella-plasty is required to de-rotate the tip of the nose and remove excess cartilage and skin that's hanging down. Choose your second surgeon very wisely based on extensive experience.

You have both alar retraction and a hanging columella with a short nose. Based solely on these pictures I recommend you consider lifting the columella, placement of a septal extension graft to lengthen the nose, and possibly an alar rim graft of cartilage to improve the contour of the nostril rim. See an experienced revision specialist.