Is my skin not stretchy enough for a rhinoplasty revision raising of the bridge & lengthening/remove upturned nose top?

Hello, this is Dr.Lee from VIP PS, Seoul, Korea.
*Please understand that this answer is limited as I did not have a chance to diagnose and examine your nose in-person.
Based on the two surgeons' answers and photos, it seems like your skin is very thin and upturned due to contraction from previous surgeries. In order to lengthen the upturned nose, the best material is the rib cartilage from my experience. Rib cartilage is the autologous tissue naturally formed from your body. It has a vast amount that can be harvested and designed in a way that we wish to achieve - lengthening and heightening are all possible. Septal and ear cartilage are too small and weak to support the upturned nose. I would also not recommend any artificial material such as silicone as it could further cause contraction. Another important aspect in succeeding this revision rhinoplasty would be your skin elasticity. I have not examined your nose skin yet, but there may be a limited amount that your nose skin can be stretched. Ultimately, finding a balance between the extent of lengthening using the rib cartilage and providing enough stretch in your nose skin would be the key in this revision rhinoplasty. Please see before and after photos I have performed on the upturned nose.
Hope this answer was helpful.
Thanks,
Dr.Lee