Would I benefit from a donut breast lift? (photos)

You are absolutely not a candidate for a donut lift (very few people are, and those that are end up not getting a lift because their nipple position is close to 'normal'). Your breasts hang, and your nipples are at the bottom of the hanging portion facing downwards. Only a true breast lift that contains a vertical component will give you a lovely breast shape. Check to make sure the doc you've visited is really board certified, and has lots of examples of 'anchor scar' lifts. In addition, ask the doc to show you pics of women with breasts like yours that got a donut lift.

A donut breast lift, also known as a periareolar mastopexy, involves removing excess skin and tightening around the areola to lift the breast. It is typically recommended for women with mild sagging or those seeking only a slight lift. A donut lift might is not the best option for you if your breasts have significant ptosis (sagging), with nipples pointing downward and located below the breast fold.
A more extensive lifts like the anchor lift (wise pattern) or lollipop (vertical) lift is more appropriate . These techniques provide a more comprehensive lift and reshape the breast better, especially when there is a significant amount of sagging.
If your primary concern is to improve breast shape and elevate the nipple, a full breast lift with an anchor incision is likely a better solution. The donut lift would not offer as much elevation or fullness, and there are concerns about it potentially flattening the breast or leading to stretched scars.
It’s crucial to consult with an experienced plastic surgeon who can examine your specific anatomy and discuss your goals in more detail before making a decision.
Krishna Vyas, MD, PhD, MHSHarvard, Hopkins, & Mayo Clinic Trained Aesthetic Plastic SurgeonNew York, New York

Just based on your photos, you need the vertical lift. I would not do the anchor lift on you. The doughnut may not be sufficient and may leave your breasts somewhat wide.