Alarplasty suitability and tip reduction opinions in UK please? (photo)

In your professional opinion am I best suited to an alarplasty? Especially considering the further implications of a rhinoplasty, I think an open rhino may be over the top. I am most concerned with my flaring nostrils and could live without the slight tip reduction that I've been told would be ideal. If I was to go for tip deduction alongside an alarplasty, wouldn't a closed op be better over an open op? Many thanks for your input.