Is a nurse anesthetist as safe as an anesthesiologist?

Thanks for your question! We have used both in our practice and currently use a nurse anesthetist. They have been extremely professional, thorough and we happily continue to use them. Good luck!

While both nurse anesthetists and anesthesiologists are trained professionals, the choice between them may depend on various factors, including the complexity of the procedure and the patient's health. Your surgeon and the facility's accreditation are positive indicators, but it's advisable to discuss your concerns directly with your surgeon. They can provide insights into the specific anesthesia plan for your surgery and address any questions or preferences you may have.

Best of luck !

Hello gdenisse0630,

Thank you for your question about the safety of using a nurse anesthetist compared to an anesthesiologist during surgery. It's a common question, and I'm glad you're seeking clarification.

Firstly, it's important to understand the difference in training between a nurse anesthetist (CRNA) and an anesthesiologist. A CRNA is a registered nurse who has completed additional specialized training in anesthesia, while an anesthesiologist is a medical doctor who has completed medical school and additional training in anesthesia.

In terms of safety, numerous studies have shown that nurse anesthetists provide safe and effective anesthesia care comparable to their physician counterparts. The critical factor is the experience and the training of the individual providing the anesthesia, rather than the specific title they hold.

In your case, it's reassuring to know that your surgeon operates in an AAAASF accredited facility and is double board certified. Accreditation standards require that the anesthesia services, whether provided by a CRNA or an anesthesiologist, adhere to stringent safety and quality guidelines.

Ultimately, the decision may also depend on the complexity of the procedure and your medical history. Some complex cases might benefit from the involvement of an anesthesiologist due to their extensive medical training. However, for most standard procedures, a CRNA can safely administer anesthesia.

I always recommend discussing any concerns you have about anesthesia with your surgeon and the anesthesia provider. They can provide specific information based on your health, the surgical procedure, and the anesthesia plan.

Sincerely,
Dr. Katzen

This has actually been studied over and over . As long as you are healthy you would be as safe with a nurse anesthetist. If you would be more comfortable with a physician anesthesiologist you can always request one or have your surgery elsewhere

Certified registered nurse anesthetists as well as anesthesiologists are regular team members during plastic surgery. Both can deliver high quality, safe care. The best choice will vary based on the patient's health history and planned procedure. I encourage you to discuss your concerns with your surgeon for further clarification.

Both the nurse and the physician are usually well trained. I have worked with both and use both. If your surgeon is happy with the anesthesia provider, then you can be content.

Each professional those job. While anesthesia provided by both of these rolls are significantly different times. An anesthesiologist to strain in the full spectrum of medicine and is perhaps better suited to address patients with critical illness and complex metabolic problems. Having said that, there are numerous studies that demonstrate anesthesia provided by nurse anesthetist are as safe as with an anesthesiologist for most noncritical situations.

Nurse anesthetist is not a Dr. however the service and care they provide is generally excellent.

Great question is presented. The main reason for using CRNA over anesthesiologist is $$$s and limited availibility to find anesthesiologist. I use both options. If the patient desires only MD anesthesia then I accommodate them, but fee is higher. hope this clears things up for you...

I speak to you in a personal and particular way, in Mexico we make sure that the people who work with us are certified and trained to perform the appropriate functions, in Mexico only anesthesiologists can give anesthesia.