Would Mentor classic smooth be much more likely to rippling than Mentor Xtra smooth?

Mentor Xtra Smooth implants are designed with additional layers to minimize the risk of visible rippling. However, the likelihood of rippling also depends on individual factors such as skin thickness, tissue coverage, and the specific implant size chosen.
Given your preferences and concerns, it would be advisable to discuss these details thoroughly with your surgeon during your consultation.
Dr. Safa Manav

It is a very good choice to have it placed under the muscle. This is your best insurance against rippling, although you might expect to feel the implant on the outer side of the breast. The Mentor extra is more cohesive, and may decrease the risk of rippling a little. Unfortunately, nothing is guaranteed when the tissue coverage is so minimal. Good luck with your surgery.

Thank you for your question. It would be helpful to provide photos and the base dimensions of your breasts. That being said yes the regular gel implant has a slightly higher risk of rippling than the Xtra gel implant. You should discuss this with your PS. I hope this helps