Hi angeldoc, UNDEREYE DARKNESS- People with hollowing of their lower eyelid area have a lid/cheek junction which separates the lower eyelid to the upper cheek. If the junction itself is not elevated and the cheek is plumped up more, it will not help the hollowed area very much, unless the injector is actually filling the lid cheek junction to blend the “eyebag” into the upper cheek. The concern your doctor has is that in order to fill this area some filler would need to be placed over the eyebag area which they worry it will make the eyebag larger. But if the filler is placed over the orbital septum it will press the orbital septum down, which should flatten the lower edge of the eyebag. If the injection is performed deep or under the orbital septum, this will inflate the eyebag and balloon out the orbital septum causing the eyebag to become even bigger yet not actually fill out the lid-cheek junction due to the orbital retaining ligament. One issue that may happen that I see in your photos is that your left cheek had a malar crescent/festoon. Sometimes this technique can cause the malar festoons to get puffier, so that is another consideration. LOWER FACE LIFTING- The amount of filler needed on the apples of the cheeks would need to be an inordinate amount. You currently have 3 convexities. The lower eyelid is convex between the lower eyelashes to the tear trough and life cheek junction. Your cheek and nasolabial fat pad is convex from the lid cheek junction to the paranasal and nasolabial fold. And your upper lip area would be another convexity. Current filling strategies tend to fill already convex areas and make them more convex. When I look at peoples younger faces, I don’t see giant apple cheeks and huge lips, instead I see smooth gentle convexity from the lower eyelashes down the cheek past the nasolabial fold down to the jawline. So if we like how we look when we are younger, the strategy would be to fill the concave areas to blend them into the convex areas and make the multiple sections blend smoothly into a more uniform highlight. Fillers fill, so do we fill concavities or do we plump convexities even more while ignoring the concavities. Fillers in the eyelid area appears to last many years before wanting a small touch up. Patients are not completely refilling the same area over and over again every year. The results are quite stable over the years. My longest patients without a touch up are 6-7 years and counting. To keep realistic expectations, I tell patients they can expect 18-24 months before considering a touch up in the eyelid area assuming they are not over exercising and trying to treat facial fat as an enemy. Hope you found this helpful. Good luck on your facial rejuvenation journey. Best, Dr. Yang