Want to correct eyelids: should I get a blepharoplasty or another procedure? (photo)

I would like to correct my eyelids, but I am having trouble finding a treatment. I was told that blepharoplasty may overcorrect the problem, but I have been told that I am not a candidate for several non-surgical procedures because they would not resolve the fat and puffiness bothering me. What are the opinions here? Is blepharoplasty my only option? Or is there another issue to correct that I'm not aware of and can bring up to a surgeon? Thank you for your help!