Revision rhino tip not what I was expecting, could I correct with anything other than another surgery?

I don't like your result. I could tell better with better photos, but from these that you posted, it looks very much as though you should not allow your last surgeon to operate on your nose again. There are just too many problems with the result.

The good news is that, in expert hands, it's likely that a lot of improvement is possible. Certainly one of the main tasks would be to make the nose look natural.

You need to be very careful in selecting your next surgeon.