Can this lump on my eyelid be surgically removed? (Photos)

It is in a location where it could be herniated eyelid fat. The fact of the matter, you need a detailed examination. Your potential surgeon will need to physically examine your eyelid to make an educated guess regarding the nature of this lesion. if seems likely to be a chalazia, it is possible that treatment could be a kenalog injection. However if this seems more likely to be herniated fat, surgery is needed to address it. I recommend seeing a fellowship trained oculoplastic surgeon. The American Society for Ophthalmic Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, the Oculofacial Society maintains a regional directory on their website that can help you find a highly qualified surgeon close to home that you can see.

This is really not in the correct location for a chalazion, but it still might be. It is not possible to give you an answer form these photos. You need to see a fellowship trained Oculoplastc surgeon for an in person exam and consultation. Typically these are daily easy to remove, but you need to see an Oculoplastic surgeon to determine if any vital structures such as your tear drainage apparatus are involved.