Would a closed rhinoplasty be sufficient to reduce my bulbous tip? (Photo)

Yes, you
could get a nice result with a closed rhinoplasty. Addressing the bump and
narrowing the nose can be done just as well from a closed approach as an open.
However, although it is possible to get a nice result with a closed
rhinoplasty, elevating the skin allows much more flexibility in modifying the
tip shape without removing too much cartilage (which can result in loss of
support and a pinched or asymmetric tip). Although I used to perform
exclusively closed rhinoplasties, now I perform more than 90% open. I feel that
my results are more reliable with fewer revisions. I see no problems with the
scars, and with careful technique, I do not feel that the recovery is
significantly longer. However, there are a variety of opinions on this subject.
Best wishes for your decision and your surgery.

 The optimal way to correct a
bulbous tip is to do an open approach over a closed approach as this allows you
to see the bulbous tip correctly. It is important to find a Board Certified
Plastic Surgeon or Otolaryngologist with expertise in Rhinoplasty. This is the
key to excellent results; no matter whether it is open versus a closed
rhinoplasty.

Dear katiebow1,With your nose, you can likely achieve your goals using the closed approachYou should visit a rhinoplasty specialist in your area who can address your concernsA full exam would be necessary to determine and go over your optionsBest regards,Nima Shemirani