If you're contemplating performing a primary rhinoplasty, there's no reason to have a visible external scar on your columella with an open rhinoplasty. Your diagnosis of EDS will not matter moving forward regarding a rhinoplasty procedure. With closed rhinoplasty, the incisions are completely located on the inside of the nose, there's no external incisions, and no painful packing either. A closed rhinoplasty procedure avoids the visible external visible, heals much faster with a less swelling and numbness in the nasal tip. The open versus closed is only about the approach on how you get in the nose, not the individual maneuvers that are performed on the nasal structures internally. Many examples of closed rhinoplasty, please see the link below to our closed rhinoplasty photo gallery.