Overcorrected eyelid or overdone blepharoplasty on my left eye? Should I get another doctor to correct it. (photo)

Hello and thank you for your excellent question. Based on your photos it appears that initially the right side had more ptosis, this causes the muscles on both sides to contract and lift the lids. After the right lid was fixed the muscles stopped contracting and this caused the left lid to become more ptotic (Herring's Law). You would likely require more correction of the left side. I recommend you seek consultation with a board certified plastic surgeon who can help guide you in your decision making.

Hi there,
There are two issues with the asymmetry.  One issue is that the left brow is elevated, versus the right side.  This may be your brain's effort to compensate for the second issue:  left upper eyelid droop (ptosis).  The net effect of these two problems is that each of them makes MORE of your left upper lid visible.  This increases the asymmetric appearance.  Revision ptosis surgery on the left upper lid is the first step:  this will raise your lid, and decrease the "tarsal platform", or amount of eyelid that is visible.  This will improve symmetry.  HOPEFULLY, the left brow will relax down a little bit -- this may provide you with near perfect symmetry if that happens.  If not, that might need to be addressed sometime later with a minor procedure.
Revision surgery would have perhaps an 80-90% chance of correction with a single procedure.  It would be done awake, and would take about 20 minutes.  
Hope that helps
JDW

I agree you have some asymmetry after your surgery.  You may want to first discuss your concerns with your surgeon to see if he or she has any suggestions on how to address the issues.  However, if you feel more comfortable with a different surgeon, be sure they are experienced with eyelid and ptosis surgery.  Best of luck.