Why do many celebrities that have had their eyes ‘done’ seem to have smaller eyes afterwards?

Thank you for your question.  While poorly performed eyelid surgery can lead to an unnatural appearance, there are excellent eyelid surgeons who can produce a natural, youthful outcomes without a telltale "done" look.  The key used to perform the surgical procedure that will best address each patient's needs.  I would strongly recommend seeking surgery with someone who focuses on eyelid rejuvenation.  Best of luck. 

Thank you for that interesting observation. The reason behind the perceived smaller eyes could be that filler was added beneath the eye. The added volume could create that effect. I encourage you to find an experienced, board-certified plastic surgeon who performs blepharoplasty all the time. Ask to see numerous before and after photos of previous patients. If you do not see that effect in these photos, you can rest assured your surgeon likely knows the proper techniques to perform this procedure without looking “done.” 

If your goal is to reduce some of the excess skin and open up your eyelid area from aging, then this should not change the shape or position of your eyelids. That being said, a lot of people and perhaps celebrities want to change the way they look and either have a lot of fat removed or may have developed some eyelid drooping either from the surgery or had it unmasked after the surgery. In general, eyelid surgery should be done to make the eyelids appear more youthful and not alter the appearance of the eyelids themselves.

There could be many reasons for this finding.  Three common reasons would include unrecognized upper eyelid ptosis that may not have been noticed prior, and the removal of skin no longer makes the patient compensate by lifting his or her brow.  There could also be a laxity of the lower lid, and tightening the lower lid brings that outer corner up, thus narrowing the eye opening.  The third could be adding filler to the lower lid/cheek region, which can change their look.  I recommend looking at many before and after photos of surgeons in your area to get a better idea of results.  

The surgery causes the upper eyelid ptosis, upper eyelid hollows, compensatory eyebrow elevation, upper eyelid lash ptosis, and crepey upper eyelid skin, a high or absent upper eyelid crease. Upper blepharoplasty does not need to cause this but avoiding it requires the understanding that weakness in the upper eyelid tendon needs to be correct at the time of cosmetic upper blepharoplasty. It is not routine to address the weakness that is present in the aging eyelid. The result is awful surgical results even in our celebrities. The sad thing is that when those who can get care with anyone, can't find a good result, what chance does anyone else have. I assure you, that if you choose the right surgeon, your eyes do not have to be small after cosmetic eyelid surgery.

Thank you for your questions. Without a specific celebrity in mind plus before and after photos, it is hard to comment on what you are noticing. However, some amount of swelling is a normal part of healing, which, after an upper eyelid blepharoplasty for instance, can for a few weeks to months make the eyes look smaller or less open. It is unusual for swelling to cause frank eyelid ptosis, and may be an indication of a problem if it does, but there is a possibility that what you're noticing is related to postoperative swelling. Hope this helps!

A well performed blepharoplasty should look very natural.  The appearance of a smaller eye can be that the overall aperture of the entire orbital area has been narrowed which is a rejuvenated look vs having an overly wide eyelid area. Another possibility is the effect of a canthopexy to tighten the lower eyelid if it was previously lax and sagging, another effect of rejuvenation if not too exaggerated which could then look unnatural. The dynamics of a lower eyelid operation can be complex and you need to be evaluated by an experienced surgeon with a particular interest in blepharoplasty

Without a set of pictures, it is difficult  ton give a definitive answer. When lots of fillers are placed in the cheeks, it tends to make the eyes smaller. The primary goal for upper eyelid surgery is hooded skin removal, while the primary goal for lower eyelid surgery is to remove the fat bags creating the puffy look