Skin Pinch in Cheek Lift?

The lower eyelid is a very weak structure. Maintaining an almond shape is important for mainatining a normal eye appearance.
When skin is removed from the lower eyelid, a downward pull is exerted on the lower eyelid. The greater the amount of skin removed, the looser the lower eyelid, or the more prominent the eyeball is in the eye socket, the more downward pull there is when skin is removed, and the greater the resulting deformity. This deformity usually manifests as a pulling down of the lower eyelid, a rounding of the eye, or a "sad", downgoing appearance of the eye.
One method of retaining eye shape is by supporting the corner of the eye, not just with a canthopexy (tightening of the lower yelid), but of elevating the cheek tissue, essentially "giving" it to the lower eyelid. The tension then does not rely on removing from the lower eyelid, but rather from an elevation of the cheek. Then, a small amount of skin can more safely be removed, tightening the skin with minimal risk of affecting eye shape.
A great risk of lower eyelid surgery is in scarring that can occur within the orbital septum, pulling down severely on the lower eyelid, or of removing too much skin from the lower eyelid, causing an ectropion. This can be avoided not with an incision that goes completely across the lower eyelid (therefore affecting the orbital septum), but with an ultrashort incision just on the side of the eye, the ultrashort incision cheeklift, or USIC cheeklift.

A skin pinch can make an improvement in excess lower lid skin when it is present in the lower lid's natural state. You have to be very careful when doing it in combination with a cheeklift, though, because the natural state is shifted when a cheeklift is done.
Obviously, when the cheek is pulled up, it will look like there is extra skin present. However, if all the excess is removed with a skin pinch, then when the cheek tissue relaxes, and it always does, it could pull the lower eyelid down with it, resulting in a deformity.
Make sure you speak with surgeons who are well experienced in performing this type of surgery.
Dr. Miller

Dear Jackster212,
There are almost as many variations on mid-face/lower eyelid surgery as there are surgeons performing these procedures. This means that individuals considering these procedures should approach unsubstantiated claims regarding the success of a particular approach with a critical eye. The take home message when there are so many surgical approaches to the same area is that nothing works for everyone. There is no secret surgical fix that addressed the lower eyelid issues for all patients.
The so-called ultra short incision cheeklift is just what one surgeon calls their transcutaneous lower blepharoplasty when combined with some supporting stitches to help keep the weight of the cheek off the lower eyelid once some skin has been removed and the tissues contract from scaring. Does this procedure work? For the right person this can be a very workable solution. The rub is that for the wrong person, this procedure will not be right. So how do you know what you need?
The answer is that there is no substitute for finding the right doctor, who will personally assess you and design a surgery that meets your goals, expectations, and anatomic issues. Unfortunately this means finding a surgeon with the ability to adapt and alter their approach to fit your particular circumstance. Cookie cutter surgery is almost always going to produce an unsatisfactory result.
Don't sell yourself on a particular surgery or approach. Seek multiple opinions and see who makes the most sense. They say don't fall in love with a stock. Well, we surgeons think that the chemistry of confidence is very important. But try to not let it be love at first sight. Carefully listen to the surgeon, be aware of the level of detail of their assessment. How are their powers of observation and insight.
Finally, study their before and after pictures. Ask yourself if you like what you see, are the results plausible for you? Google your doctor so you have done your homework on them and consider contacting the state medical board where your doctor practices to determine if their are any disciplinary actions against your potential surgeon.