Why do so many post-facelift patients have an indentation on the upper mid-cheek and strange jawline skin?

MommyLJ.   Facelift techniques differ, and some techniques offer better, more natural results than others.  Facelifts that pull the skin laterally can create a very unnatural appearance. For this reason choosing an experienced board certified plastic surgeon is the most important decision.  Do your research and ask questions about technique during consultations. Good luck!

Your reluctance is justified.  Artistic virtuosos of facelift are rare among many performers.  The “lateral sweep” and other visible hallmarks of shortcut approaches are indeed common, and perhaps more detrimental to dignity than normal aging features.  However, you’ll enjoy many years of youth if you find a master and endure a month or so of swelling and distortion that comprehensive natural rejuvenation by skillful re-positioning of soft tissues demands.