Told have to have belly button REMOVED completely with Tummy Tuck and umbilical hernia repair surgery. HELP!

I agree that most of the time one can preserve the umbilicus. When I do not want to risk a poor hernia repair just to save the umbilicus then I make a new one it can look better then the original. Good Luck!

Sometimes the blood supply to the belly button is altered by the hernia causing there to be minimal blood supply to the belly button after the surgery. This can result in the belly button not living and creating an infection risk especially if you have mesh placed to repair the hernia. So, to answer your question, sometimes you don't have to remove the belly button, but other times, you do.Your surgeon who has examined you is the only one who can make the decision

Belly bitton removal is very rare. There may be problems with circulation due to the hernia. Discuss more with your plastic surgeon or consider a 2nd opinion. 

Tummy tuck procedures often involve a repair of an umbilical hernia with the repair of the diastasis. We do these procedures regularly without the need of a general surgeon and can always spare the natural umbilicus. Your concern is understood and might need a revisit.

Without photos and more specifics, this question is absolutely impossible to answer.  I have resected the umbilicus myself with a tummy tuck. I also have repaired it with modified and full abdominoplasty techniques.   Having been fully trained and boarded in general surgery as well as plastic surgery, I have performed tummy tucks along with hernia repairs my entire career.  In this situation, I can answer patient questions that relate to both procedures.  I would recommend that you either get your two surgeons to address your concerns or find one that can perform both for you. Best of luck