Would a columelloplasty fix this hanging columella? (Photo)

You have both nostril retraction ( nostrils have risen up ) and true columella excess - you are correct that just lifting the columella area would make your tip too turned up - you need the tip rotated downwards, the nostril rims lowered and some elevation of the hanging columella - this will not be easy and requires a specialist reversional rhinoplasty surgeon and possibly some additional cartilage grafts if your septum has already been used previously

I can see what you are concerned about. You have what we call "excessive columellar show." This can be due to a hanging columella, nostril retraction or a combination of the two. Excessive columellar show in patients who've had a previously rhinoplasty is almost always due to nostril retraction. I suspect that the tip refinement you had during your rhinoplasty included removing some of this cartilage which weakens the nostrils and sides of the nose. The scar forces overwhelm the strength of the remaining cartilage and the result is nostril retraction that develops slowly over many years. This is not an easy problem to fix. You will need an in-person exam and consultation with a very experienced revision rhinoplasty expert to discuss possible solutions. Best of luck!!