Both products are HA fillers. The main difference is the G prime of Restylane Lyft is 554 and Voluma is 274. This is a measure of its lifting ability in tissue samples. The Voluma folks argue that this is not the only measure that should be relied upon to determine what is best for the cheeks. They argue that Voluma integrates better with the tissue and gives a better result. Longevity is also touted to be longer - 2 years - with Voluma BUT that is when 6 syringes were used and there were touch ups. Lyft is FDA approved to say it lasts 12 months. I'm currently doing a cheek challenge with each, injecting one side with Lyft and the other with Voluma. It has only been one month, and at this point, things appear to be equal. I'll keep posting updates on YouTube and my Facebook. Voluma is also going to run more expensively because it is more cost to the doctor.
UPDATE: CHEEK CHALLENGE RESULTS - Voluma and Lyft both lasted 12 months. No significant differences in duration. Link has more details.
Restylane Lyft and Juvederm Voluma are both excellent fillers when used properly. Lyft is manufactured by Galderma and was previously called Perlane, and Voluma is from Allergan. Lyft can be used in the midface as well as in the lower face, whereas Voluma is primarily intended for the midface (cheeks). Lyft has clinical studies demonstrating a duration of one year, whereas Voluma has been demonstrated to last up to two years.
Beyond these differences, they are both hyaluronic acid fillers that are excellent for providing volume in the midface and sculpting the cheeks. Consult with an experienced provider who can help determine which product will best meet your needs. In the right hands, both products can provide beautiful, natural results.
Restylane Lyft and Juvederm Voluma are very similar products. Lyft is sold my Galderma and Voluma by Allergan. It is kind of like Sony and Samsung when it comes to consumer electronics. They are both great companies. There is a difference in price because of what the companies charge. As far as the products they are both hyaluronic acid based, both are larger particles than other HA fillers, and both have greater crosslinking than other HA fillers to make them last longer. Voluma has a study showing it lasted up to two years. Lyft ended its study at 1 year so it can only claim to last that long.
I hope this helps and good luck.
Both are great products and I use quite a bit of each. Voluma is more expensive and they have data that suggests that it lasts up to two years when patients obtain full correction. Restylane Lyft was recently approved by the FDA for the mid-face, but was previously known as Perlane.
The techniques to inject them are largely similar and I would say that who is injecting it is much more important than which product you chose to use.
You are correct, they are manufactured and regulated by two separate companies. Additionally, they are similar products called Hyaluronic Acid (HA). They are both utilized for providing lifting and augmentation in the cheek regions. Voluma is generally more expensive and is a newer product. Lyft is an older product that has been rebranded and approved for similar use. Both products are great options when used correctly. I personally inject Voluma and find the results to last between 1-2 years depending on the patient and result desired.
Both Lyft and Voluma are hyaluronic acid fillers. I get excellent results with either of these fillers for cheek augmentation. Voluma may possibly last longer, but it is more expensive. In my opinion, your choice of injector is more important than the specific filler. Good injectors can get excellent results with either filler. In general, I prefer to use a cannula for cheek augmentation, which truly makes this a non-invasive, no downtime procedure.
Thanks for your question. These products are very different, and are made by different companies entirely. While they are both hyaluronic acid (HA) fillers, their level of cross linking is different which leads to differences in how they feel when injected and how long their results last. I feel that Juvederm Voluma does a better job overall revolumizing the cheeks and temples, though often it costs more than Restylane Lyft. The latter product was known for years as Perlane and has simply been rebranded as Restylane Lyft after testing to get FDA approval for marketing it to inject into cheeks and the mid face. I hope this helps!
Yes, these are fillers made by different, competing companies. Yes, they are both hyaluronic acid fillers. The difference is in the cross-linking meaning how tight and small the HA particle is. In my opinion, Voluma plumps better and longer than Restylane Lyft (which is Perlane repackaged) in the upper cheek and face region. There may be a price difference because the prices will depend on volume discounts to the physicians for how many syringes they order over a year. In most places, Voluma will cost more.
"This answer has been solicited without seeing this patient and cannot
be held as true medical advice, but only opinion. Seek in-person
treatment with a trained medical professional for appropriate care."
Allergan and Galderma are competing filler companies. They both make a wide range of fillers. Lyft and Voluma are the more dense fillers which are cross linked in a similar fashion and made to be injected more deeply. These hyaluronic acid fillers are both long lasting 12-24 months depending on which peer reviewed study is referenced.
Lyft and Voluma are about the same. They both last about 12 months and work great for cheek enhancement and midface lift.
I suggest you meet with an experienced injector and rely on their expertise.
Best wishes, Dr. ALDO