Does my nose look botched? (Photos)

From your photos it appears you have an increased columellar on the right. It's quite possible that your internal valve has been narrowed too much causing you breathing difficulties. These are aesthetic considerations that you need to discuss with your surgeon who might be able to offer you a revision surgery. 

No, your results are not what you like and a revision rhinoplasty done by a very experienced revision rhinoplasty surgeon can get you a nose closer to what you want. All rhinoplasty surgeons have to deal with scarring after surgery which can alter results. 

Hello,You got a 'closed rhinoplasty' for certain, and therefore it is likely that you got a 'reduction rhinoplasty' only.  That is to say, the surgeon probably only removed tissue, and did not reinforce the remaining tissue with rigidly fixed cartilage grafts or reshape your native cartilage with sutures. This has lead to a loss of function (diminished airway) and less than normal looking form (alar arching).  You could benefit from a revision rhinoplasty where cartilage is harvested from your septum and utilized to reinforce your existing cartilage as well as augment areas of laxity that allow collapse (internal valve). Additionally, a portion of your tip cartilage complex could be repositioned, which could have a dramatic effect on alar position and shape, as well as improving airflow (external valve). Go visit a few surgeons who specialize in structural rhinoplasty. Best of luck!