As the other surgeons have discussed, the belly button remains attached to the abdominal wall and is sewn to the overlying abdominal skin. If a large cuff of skin is left on the belly button, the ultimate appearance will be a scar around the belly button, much like a bulls eye, which is not the most aesthetic result. If a smaller amount of skin is left on the belly button before attaching it to the abdominal skin and the new hole in the abdominal skin is small then the scar will be along the edge of the belly button and less visible. One issue I have seen occasionally is that smaller, round scar is that it can contracting (shrink) as it heals. It is normal for scars to contract as they heal and the amount of contracture is different for everyone. If it contracts a lot then it will pull in, much like a purse string. That narrows the opening of the belly button. The treatment for that problem can be as simple as time and allowing the scar to relax, steroid injections, or a minor surgical procedure that can be performed in the office. Depending on your exam and how long after your surgery, your surgeon can advise you on the best course. I hope this helps.