My mother had breast cancer in her early 40s. I am 23 and recently had a consultation. I was told that saline implants would be best for future detection. I believe mainly due to capsular contracture. I hadn’t decided yet but I was leaning towards silicone for the most natural look possible. I really appreciate his concern for my risk and safety but I’m just curious to see if other doctors agree that saline might be my safest/only option or if anyone thinks silicone could still be a safe option
Answer: Silicone vs. Saline There are pros and cons to both silicone and saline implants. It's important that you discuss each with your surgeon in order to make the best decision for you. Both are safe to use. Mammograms can detect cancer with either in place. It is suggested you go behind the muscle., which will also give you a more natural look. You may also want to look into BRCA testing. This simple blood test can help detect your risk for certain breast cancers.
Helpful
Answer: Silicone vs. Saline There are pros and cons to both silicone and saline implants. It's important that you discuss each with your surgeon in order to make the best decision for you. Both are safe to use. Mammograms can detect cancer with either in place. It is suggested you go behind the muscle., which will also give you a more natural look. You may also want to look into BRCA testing. This simple blood test can help detect your risk for certain breast cancers.
Helpful
April 6, 2022
Answer: Silicone vs saline hx of breast CA Hello, thank you for your excellent question. If there is a family history of breast CA(cancer) then there are several factors to consider. The first is if there is a family history of breast CA have you thought about genetic testing for the BRCA gene, secondly you will have to go for mammograms and early screening prior to the age of which your mom was diagnosed. The main difference between saline and silicone for the purpose of detecting breast CA is obtaining an MRI with silicone implants vs saline the ultrasound alone will be helpful in early detection. As time goes on and hoping medicine/science advances, maybe they will improve the ability to detect breast CA early on. You will want to consider the pros and cons of each option. Overall you will have to choose what is the best option for you. Consider speaking to your Plastic Surgeon and your family doctor.
Helpful
April 6, 2022
Answer: Silicone vs saline hx of breast CA Hello, thank you for your excellent question. If there is a family history of breast CA(cancer) then there are several factors to consider. The first is if there is a family history of breast CA have you thought about genetic testing for the BRCA gene, secondly you will have to go for mammograms and early screening prior to the age of which your mom was diagnosed. The main difference between saline and silicone for the purpose of detecting breast CA is obtaining an MRI with silicone implants vs saline the ultrasound alone will be helpful in early detection. As time goes on and hoping medicine/science advances, maybe they will improve the ability to detect breast CA early on. You will want to consider the pros and cons of each option. Overall you will have to choose what is the best option for you. Consider speaking to your Plastic Surgeon and your family doctor.
Helpful
April 6, 2022
Answer: Implants Both saline and silicone are safe and both are placed behind your breast tissue. Going behind the breast does not obstruct in future X-rays or exams. Since saline implants' only foreign material is the bag, they may be somewhat safer. Also, saline implants do not block X-rays. Saline implants are more firm and may show ripples. If you have minimal breast tissue or want to go with a large size, you will probably be happier with silicone.
Helpful
April 6, 2022
Answer: Implants Both saline and silicone are safe and both are placed behind your breast tissue. Going behind the breast does not obstruct in future X-rays or exams. Since saline implants' only foreign material is the bag, they may be somewhat safer. Also, saline implants do not block X-rays. Saline implants are more firm and may show ripples. If you have minimal breast tissue or want to go with a large size, you will probably be happier with silicone.
Helpful
April 4, 2022
Answer: Implant type Dear BaileySmith06,
Helpful
April 4, 2022
Answer: Implant type Dear BaileySmith06,
Helpful
April 3, 2022
Answer: Implant type for family history of breast cancer - what is the safest option? Hello @BaileySmith06 thank you for your question. I understand your concern. However, without a proper assessment an expert opinion is not possible. The best course of action is to consult one or several board certified plastic surgeon for more information and options tailored specifically to your needs. Best wishes! Alan Gonzalez MD FACS
Helpful
April 3, 2022
Answer: Implant type for family history of breast cancer - what is the safest option? Hello @BaileySmith06 thank you for your question. I understand your concern. However, without a proper assessment an expert opinion is not possible. The best course of action is to consult one or several board certified plastic surgeon for more information and options tailored specifically to your needs. Best wishes! Alan Gonzalez MD FACS
Helpful
