Can Your Nose Cartilage Be Broken Even if X-rays Are Negative?

August 5, 2012
Asked By:mgsondance

I fell onto my face, and had severe bleeding from the R side of my nose for about 5'. It swelled but there was not much bruising. I had a large hematoma under my top lip. The urgent care doc said that my septum was a bit off to the R. It's been 2 weeks and my nose is still acutely painful, especially if I put my finger inside the R side of the nose and press inward, even a tiny bit. Is it possible for the cartilage to be broken even if the bones aren't?

Answers (7)

From board-certified doctors and trusted medical professionals
MOST RECENT
September 12, 2016

Answer: Facial bone x-rays may not be helpful for diagnosing and managing a nasal fracture.

Eric M. Joseph, MDBoard Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
Book a virtual consultation
MOST RECENT
September 12, 2016

Answer: Facial bone x-rays may not be helpful for diagnosing and managing a nasal fracture.

Eric M. Joseph, MDBoard Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
Book a virtual consultation
August 10, 2012

Answer: Broken Cartilage Not Seen In X-Ray

Jaime Perez, MDBoard Certified Plastic Surgeon
Book a consultation
August 10, 2012

Answer: Broken Cartilage Not Seen In X-Ray

Jaime Perez, MDBoard Certified Plastic Surgeon
Book a consultation
August 8, 2012

Answer: You don't need X-Rays to diagnose a broken nose, plus they may be negative

Steven J. Pearlman, MD, FACSBoard Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
Book a virtual consultation
August 8, 2012

Answer: You don't need X-Rays to diagnose a broken nose, plus they may be negative

Steven J. Pearlman, MD, FACSBoard Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon
Book a virtual consultation
FIND THE RIGHT
TREATMENT FOR YOU

Recommended reading

Rhinoplasty

Everything you need to know about Rhinoplasty

  • 90% worth it
  • 19.4k reviews
  • Avg cost: $8,025
Learn More
ADVERTISEMENT
FIND THE RIGHT
TREATMENT FOR YOU
ADVERTISEMENT
August 7, 2012

Answer: Cartilage Problems Without a Nasal Fracture Are Certainly Possible

August 7, 2012

Answer: Cartilage Problems Without a Nasal Fracture Are Certainly Possible

January 2, 2014

Answer: Your nose can be broken even if the x-rays are normal

January 2, 2014

Answer: Your nose can be broken even if the x-rays are normal