I read ALOT. I've also restored ALOT of All-on-4 cases myself. The answer must be based on science!! The doctor that invented the procedure (Dr. Malo) published many papers on longterm followup, with good results. The All-on-4 was originally designed to replace the lower teeth, since lower conventional dentures are very poorly accepted by patients. There is more data on lower All-on-4 treatments...He will have 15 year data on these patients soon. Since there was good results on the lower, they started tracking the upper treatment outcomes, which they only have 5 year followup (soon 10yr). He looked at a couple of different things--- 1. Teeth vs. No teeth? Do success rates differ if the patient has teeth currently that need to be extracted, compared to a patient that needs the All-on-4 with no teeth at all?? Or in other words: Does the patient currently have a few missing teeth (partial edentulism) or are they already missing ALL of their teeth (full edentulism)... Does it matter?2. Upper Arch (Maxilla) vs. Lower arch (Mandible)? Bone is typically more dense in the lower mandible compared to the upper maxilla. Does it matter?Actual Success Rates for "All-on-4" implants:Lower Arch: 5 year followup: 94.8 percent (for people that had the procedure and started with full edentulism; no teeth at all) and 98.1 percent (for partial edentulism)10 year followup: 93.8 percent (started with full edentulism) and 94.8 percent (for partial edentulism)Upper Arch:5 year followup: 93 percent (full edentulism)Generally speaking, longterm success depends on many factors: patient compliance, hygiene, use of night guards, overall systemic health of patient, grinding of teeth (bruxism), general wear and tear from usage of bridges, trauma, smoking, etc.Overall, the procedure has some of the highest success rates for ANY dental procedure. However, there is a trend that the lower treatment is slightly more successful than the upper, nonetheless, BOTH are in the ++90%. The above information is for educational purposes only. You should have a consultation with your Prosthodontist and Oral Surgeon prior to any treatment.