Rhinoplasty is the most complicated surgery that we do. The surgery is only half of the issue--post operative convalescence and encouragement is the second.
The first surgery sounds like it was overdone resulting in a collapse (albeit mild) of the middle 1/3 of your nose. It may look good, but it makes it hard to breathe through your nose.
This problem was addressed in the second surgery with spreader grafts--cartilage from the septum that widens the middle 1/3rd to allow for easier breathing. It sounds like the harvest of the cartilage may have resulted in a septal perforation. The noise can also be the result of natural post-operative swelling. I routinely fix these problems for patients in my own area and often advise them that it takes 6-12 months for the swelling inside the nose to resolve before the breathing can improve.
So for you, I suggest patients if the spreader grafts were performed. However, if you have a septal perforation, you should seek out someone who can address the problem.
Breathing Complications After Rhinoplasty
Sorry for your bad experience with your rhinoplasty. Even in the best of hands sometimes unsatisfactory results may occur. Your surgeon has tried his best to get a successful result.
It sounds (no pun intended) like you may now have a perforation (a hole) in your nasal septum which would account for the noise that you are describing. If there is a perforation, it is correctable but would require another surgery.
Your breathing may benefit from reducing the size of your inferior nasal turbinates. There is a non-invasive, non-surgical method, Somnoplasty, which uses radiofrequency energy to reduce the volume of the turbinates. Hopefully you will be able to breathe well through your nose again.
You should discuss your concerns with your surgeon, and possibly get other opinions.
Good luck and be well.
Sniffling and a runny nose are both related to allergies.
It is good that you had tried the cortisone nasal sprays to try to relieve your nasal congestion. Sometimes this can occur from unrelated issues such as allergies, and the swelling from turbinates, which can be caused from allergies. Cortisone nasal sprays will help with this. Bone and cartilage would need to be removed from the nose if the patient needs a septoplasty for a preexisting deviated septum that was not addressed by primary surgery. Sniffling and a runny nose are both related to allergies.
May want to seek a second opinion
It sounds like you have been through a lot. While you may have a very good surgeon, it sounds like you have had several setbacks and unfortunate outcomes. You may want to consider a second opinion. Every time you operate on the nose, you are causing more scar tissue and destroying tissues that may be needed for a later surgery. Right now, it sounds like you need spreader grafts modified and repair of septal perforation. You may also benefit from partial turbonate resection to help your breathing. To help your breathing in the mean time, you may want to try BreatheRight strips at night. These pull open your internal valve and allow more air to flow. Good luck.
Well you have been through a long and bad experience. Having benefit of physical exam of your internal nasal structures is key to make recommendations. I can throw out thoughts however, and add to what others have said.
Too much structural cartilage was removed from the tip, thus weakening it. Inspiration (breathing in) created enough negative pressure that the nostrils collapsed, and breathing was compromised.
At this point, a secondary procedure was indicated to add support and structure to the nostrils. It sounds like you suffered a healing complication, where a hole formed in the septum that separates each nostril chamber. When you breath, you may whistle.
A small septal perforation may heal all by itself, but frequently, they require yet another operation. Fortunately, this may be covered by insurance.
My advice to you is this. A nose is not something that you can keep operating on forever. I would recommend a second opinion with a rhinoplasty surgeon wit the best reputation you can find. Fixing septal perforations is tricky, so be sure he feels comfortable with it.
Best of luck to you.
Too soon to make any judgement after Rhinoplasty
The swelling inside your nose may take 6-12 months to slowly resolve. I would be patient and ask your surgeon if you have a perforation. If you have this you may want to have it repaired along with treatment for your breathing problem if it doesn't go away. You should see a revision rhinoplasty expert to evaluate your problem.
Yours is an unfortunate story
I am sorry to hear about your troubles. I think at this point you have several problems, possibly also a septal perforation, and need to see a rhinoplasty expert. Dr. Rollin Daniel in Newport Beach CA is close to you and is considered to be an international expert. I would advise that you get your op notes and photos from your doctor and make an appointment to drive up and see him for a thorough evaluation. Hopefully something can be done to make this better!