Does an open or closed rhinoplasty yield more permanent results, prevent open roof deformity, & what are the pros/cons each?

Thank you very much for your question.As you can see, different surgeons will have different opinions regarding the approach.  I think the best approach is to find a doctor whose results you like, and in whom you have confidence to deliver the result you desire.  And then let them pick the closed vs. open technique.  Best of luck!

I won't even tell you what I prefer. Here's how you pick open vs. closed. First, you find a doctor who has great results working on noses like yours. If he passes all the tests about how to find a good rhinoplasty doctor that I list in the "Web reference" link below, then you've found your surgeon, and you let him do open or closed, whatever he thinks will work best for you in his hands!