Overexcised skin on upper eyelids and don't like my eyelid shape. Any way to get my old eyelids back? (Photo)

The skin graft is too stiff and will never fold properly. You need crease lowering surgery. This is a type of upper eyelid reconstruction that involves making a new lower eyelid crease and moving the levator aponeurosis to the new crease location. A small ptosis correction should also be performed. Preaponeurotic fat needs to be mobilized from scar tissue created by the original surgery and also brought to the new crease to contribute volume to the lowered crease. You have enough skin for this. A detailed in person assessment is essential to determine what resources are left in the eyelid from the prior surgery. Your eyes can be your best feature.

I'm sorry you are unhappy with your surgery results. Skin grafting to try to correct your previous surgery is not likely to leave you with the look you are wanting and may leave you even more unhappy. I encourage you to discuss your concerns with your surgeon for suggestions to address your concerns.

I do understand that your complaints are coming from your own esthetic perspective, each one of us has his/her own. However, as a board certified plastic surgeon and someone who has done hundreds of blepharoplasties, I personally think that your after result is better than your before based on these photos.