Overexcised skin on upper eyelids and don't like my eyelid shape. Any way to get my old eyelids back? (Photo)

Many plastic surgical procedures should be considered permanent and irreversible.
Upper eyelid blepharoplasty is one of them.
Reconstructing upper eyelid with skin grafting is typically only done after traumatic events such as burn injuries.
In uncircumcised men foreskin is the skin of choice for eyelid reconstruction.
The pictures included are insufficient to make a quality assessment.
From what we can see your outcome is fairly typical and regrets about having cosmetic surgery does not always justify having attempted revisions.
Skin grafting that your upper eyelids will leave you looking disfigured.
Accept the outcome and your choice of having the procedure and go on as is.
Any attempt at revisions are more likely to leave you disappointed.
If you want quality assessment, then I suggest scheduling in person consultations with highly experienced oculoplastic surgeons in your community.
For second opinion, consultations come prepared bringing with you a complete set of proper before and after pictures and a copy of your previous operative report.
These can be obtained from your current provider upon request.
Best,
Mats Hagstrom, MD