Your surgeon disinserted the levator aponeurosis and also gave you a very high crease. This can be fixed by lowering the upper eyelid crease, repairing the levator aponeurosis and advancing orbital fat into the upper eyelid. This will soften your appearance and make the eyes more jewel like. Study the accompanying video.
You had too much fat removed during surgery. A before picture would be helpful. When we do an upper eyelid blepharoplasty, there is fat in the upper lid which fills in the sulcus. This gives the puffy appearance to the eyelid pre-op. That fat is usually left in the middle and outer portions of the lid or you can get hollowing of the lid/crease which is what you have now. You can try some filler to the upper lid in the sulcus to try and soften the appearance.