Was wanting a more almond shaped eye with a lift, in the eyebrows. Not looking alien like but how a tight ponytail is (Photo)

Thank you for posting your question here!I will start by saying that my answer is based on the limited information and pictures provided. For a more tailored plan I would recommend you visit a plastic surgeon in person.
In most cases, achieving the cat eye/almond eye look involves performing two procedures in at the same time, a lateral canthopexy or canthoplasty and a lateral brow lift.
A canthopexy is a surgery were the outer portion of the lower eyelid is lifted using sutures, this will give you a cat eye look and will change the eye shape. A canthoplasty is another way of doing it that is a little more involved.
A brow lift is coupled with the above procedure to ensure that the brows match the new eye shape.
That being said I am not sure if it is the angle the picture was taken at or if you truly have upper eyelid droop , but it looks like you might have some element of upper eyelid droop with already elevated eyebrows which might need to be addresses as well , but for a tailored plan and better assessment I would recommend that you visit your plastic surgeon for an in person consult.
I hope this helps, Best of luck!

What you need is upper eyelid ptosis surgery with an anchor blepharoplasty. When the ptosis is corrected, the eyebrows will relax into a more natural position and you will have your look. Please be aware that there are two types of ptosis surgeries: anterior levator resection ptosis surgery and posterior approach ptosis surgery, which is also called Mueller's muscle conjunctival resection ptosis surgery. In my experience, the posterior approach ptosis surgery is not as effective as the anterior levator resection ptosis surgery and does not result in as much change in the eyebrow position. Please understand that many eyelid plastic surgeon do ptosis surgery and they all do blepharoplasty but very few specialize aesthetic reconstructive eyelid surgery, which is what you need. Your eyes can be your best feature.

to achive your desired goal we can plan a temporal lift a.k.a fox eye / almond eye / Bella eye surgery. This includes an incision inside your hair and eye browns all of temporal region and canthus of the eye ( lateral corner of the eye) can be pulled and given your desired look. also a canthopexy can be added during the same operation the give a more titled angle for your eyelids.

Typically, a canthoplasty can be used to move the lateral corner of the eyelid upward to a more pleasing position or a positive vector, as is known medically. A canthoplasty is a procedure where the lateral attachment or corner of the eyelid is moved from its current position to a more upward position in the orbit. The new upward sweep of the eyelid is typically anchored to the orbit through new attachments to the bone.
Trust your face with a craniofacial surgeon!

The wish picture is not really achievable. The major difference is centhal tilt which is based on bone structure.
You could consider ptosis surgery.
Best,
Mats Hagström MD