UTM or OTM for Extreme Hobbies?

Question

I’m heading in for a breast lift with augmentation and am trying to understand any potential future issues if I were to do UTM implants with hobbies like mountain biking and white water rafting (oar raft, rowing 75 miles in a weekend type thing). Would UTM impact performance? Would rafting/mountain biking impact results over time if it’s under the muscle/dual plane? I don’t have a lot of tissue so going over the muscle poses its own issues (plus it’s my understanding OTM at the same time as a lift can cause issues). Thanks!

Tyler Frew, MD · Answer

Hi there,
With thin tissue, I'd usually lean toward under the muscle or a dual-plane approach for better coverage and softer edges. Going over the muscle at the same time as a lift can put the implant's weight right on the newly tightened skin, which may make sagging return sooner &mdash; so your instinct there is fair.
Here's the honest trade-off for mountain biking and serious rafting:
- Under the muscle / dual plane: better camouflage when you don't have much of your own tissue, and generally lower rates of firmness (capsular contracture). The downside is animation &mdash; the implant can shift a bit when the chest muscle fires hard, which paddling and climbing both do. Some active patients notice that and adapt; a few find it bothersome.- Over the muscle: less animation and a quicker return to upper-body training, but more risk of visible edges or rippling when tissue is thin, especially with a simultaneous lift.- Subfascial placement (under the fascia but over the muscle) is a middle path some surgeons use. Worth asking about at your consult.- Smaller, cohesive gel implants often feel and look better in thin patients who stay very active.
A great way to explore size is to try implants on in a sports bra and a tight shirt, and 3D imaging such as Crisalix can show different planes and sizes on your own body. An in-person exam is needed for personal advice &mdash; especially a pinch test of your upper pole tissue.
All the best!

Kelly Schultz, MD · Answer

Great question! A 75-mile rowing weekend is a helpful detail to share with your surgeon because it gives them a much better sense of what you want to get back to after surgery.
Many active patients return to their usual sports after an under-the-muscle or dual-plane augmentation. You will likely need more time to get comfortable with strenuous upper-body activity than you would with over-the-muscle placement. Once your surgeon clears you to row, I’d ease back in with shorter outings before tackling a full weekend on the river.
With an implant partly under the muscle, you may see or feel it move when you contract your chest muscles (animation). An implant can also shift position over time, but there’s limited evidence that rowing or mountain biking after you’ve healed causes lasting changes in implant position or appearance. It’s also hard to predict how under-the-muscle placement will feel for you at that level of rowing.
Over-the-muscle placement can be combined with a lift in appropriately selected patients. The lift needs to be planned to preserve blood supply to the nipple and areola. In some cases, an internal bra can provide extra support for the implant, but you still need enough of your own tissue to camouflage its edges. For you, one of the biggest questions is how much coverage you have in the upper part of the breast. If that tissue is thin, muscle coverage can help make implant edges and rippling less visible.
A consultation with a board-certified or board-eligible plastic surgeon can help you weigh those trade-offs based on your anatomy and how much rowing you do. Best of luck!

Richard Baxter, MD · Answer

There are actually 4 options for implant placement: under muscle can be either dual plane or split muscle, and over can be subglandular or subfascial. For under muscle placement I prefer split muscle because dual plane can cause animation deformity. For over, subfascial is better. A consultation is needed to make a specific recommendation especially considering a lift at the same time.

Gary M. Horndeski, MD · Answer

Unfortunately, you have not provided photographs or told us your bra size. I recommend a breast lift using the Bellesoma. This will reshape your breast tissue creating upper pole fullness without implants, elevate them higher on the chest wall and more medial to increase your cleavage. The weight of the breast is transferred to the underlying pectoralis major muscle resulting in long term stability. Vertical scars are avoided, nipple sensation (in 95%) and the ability to breast feed are maintained. Later, fat transfers or small implants can be placed if additional volume is desired.

Best Wishes,

Gary Horndeski, M.D.

Best Wishes,

Gary Horndeski, M.D.

Fernando Ovalle Jr., MD · Answer

Hello and thank you for your question! As a board-certified plastic surgeon, I would generally reassure you that most patients with under-the-muscle (dual-plane) implants can return to activities like mountain biking and whitewater rafting without significant long-term limitations.

However, there are a few considerations. Because the pectoralis muscle is involved in activities like rowing and paddling, submuscular implants can occasionally cause discomfort, tightness, or visible implant movement with muscle contraction (known as animation deformity). Most patients regain their previous strength and function, although some notice persistent differences.

Once fully healed, these activities are unlikely to significantly compromise your results simply because the implants are under the muscle. However, repetitive muscle contraction can occasionally contribute to implant displacement over time.

With limited natural breast tissue, dual-plane placement can provide better implant coverage and reduce visible rippling. Over-the-muscle placement isn't necessarily contraindicated with a simultaneous lift, but adequate tissue coverage and thoughtful surgical planning are important.

Ultimately, I wouldn't discourage submuscular implants solely because of your hobbies. However, given how physically active you are, I would discuss these specific activities with your surgeon to determine which implant placement best balances aesthetics, long-term stability, and muscle function.

Thanks again and good luck with your journey!

Dallas Buchanan, MD · Answer

Thank you for your questions. I used to practice in Spokane! This is a great conversation that you probably need to have in detail with your board-certified plastic surgeon. There are a lot of preferences out there on this hotly debated topic, but the true answer is there are pros and cons to each, so there is no "perfect" choice. I have a lot of active patients and even some bodybuilding patients who do not want the muscle messed with, so they choose OTM placement. In addition, everyone with UTM implants has what is called animation deformity which means the implant/breast moves when the muscle flexes, and that can be bothersome to some people. However, UTM placement can offer more coverage of the implant and less visibility of the implant shape and rippling in patients who are very thin, so there can be a significant advantage there in some patients. For patients who want OTM placement, but are worried about implant support, I think the addition of synthetic mesh (internal bra) is a great addition to a procedure, especially in those who are having a lift at the same time as this weakens the supporting envelope holding everything up. One of the most common operations we perform in my practice is a breast augmentation with lift, OTM, with soft tissue mesh support. Beautiful and long lasting results that are very natural. Hope this helps and best of luck!

UTM or OTM for Extreme Hobbies?

Answers (6)

More Breast Lift with Implants Questions

Am I a good candidate for the Bellesoma breast lift?

Donut/peri areola lift - Is my surgeon’s opinion correct, or should I get a second opinion? (Photos)

Multiple consults, mixed opinions. Do I need a lift with my implants? Pretty sure the right side has Pseudoptosis. (Photos)

18 months post op - bottoming out / implants too big? (Photos)

Can I choose a a circumareolar lift with a small implant? (Photos)

What determines a good candidate with pseudoptosis to have favorable results with dual plane implants alone?

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS