I don’t think it’s appropriate for us to give recommendations on what implant size to use. This is something your plastic surgeon should be helping you with. Each plastic surgeon will have their own way of guiding patients through the implant selection process. Some plastic surgeons ask patients to make the final decision regarding implant size. Putting an implant in your bra and seeing what it looks like it’s not very accurate in my opinion. The implant doesn’t look much smaller Behind the pectoralis muscle that it does in front of your breast. Other plastic surgeons will make the final decision based on input from the patient. My personal preference has always been to work with before and after pictures of previous patients who had similar body characteristics. I asked patient to bring in ideal outcomes, especially using before and after pictures of patients with similar breast characteristics. Once I have a good understanding what the patient is hoping to achieve I bring those pictures with me to the operating room to use as reference. During surgery, I use temporary implant sizes to determine what size implant will give the desired outcome. This requires maintaining an inventory of implants or shipping back all the unused implants after the procedure. I usually have a full selection of implants at my disposal during the procedure. In my opinion, working with temporary sizers has been the most accurate in my opinion. I think the plastic surgeon isn’t a better decision to decide implant selection because they have more experience. If the patient makes the decision than the doctor is off the hook if the patient isn’t happy with the choice later on. Therefore, there is some potential risk for the provider if the surgeon makes the decision which I think is better. I don’t like talking about cup sizes and I generally work with pictures because everybody understands what small medium more larges when we look at pictures of breasts. Needing a lift with an augmentation is fairly straightforward. Your surgeon should’ve walked you through that decision making process as well. I generally recommend people consult with several providers before selecting a surgeon. Finding the right plastic surgeon is usually the most important variable most likely it’s more important than selecting between the two implants you mentioned. The hands of the right plastic surgeon everything falls into place. Average plastic surgeons deliver average results. Consistent exceptional outcomes comes from exceptional plastic surgeons. As a general statement, I don’t think patients are very good at selecting providers. By having multiple consultations people usually get better at the process. Regardless of which implant you choose, neither one would be considered aggressive and I think you’ll probably be fine either way if you want a modest outcome. Most plastic surgeons will tell you that many patients wish they would’ve chosen a larger implant during long term follow up. For that reason, many plastic surgeons encourage patients to go with the bigger implant they feel comfortable with. Implant size is obviously highly related to the size of the person. At 5 foot six and 115 pounds. You probably don’t need anything much bigger than that to see a significant improvement. Anytime, excessively large implants are used the chance of undesirable side effect, complications and need for revision surgery will go up. Because your implant selection regardless is fairly modest I think you’ll do just fine. It’s wise to not opt for excessively large implants that don’t fit the diameter of the breast. All the Best with your upcoming decision-making and procedure. Mats Hagstrom MD