Too much lid showing after eyelid surgery, how can I fix this?

There are many causes for an unnatural look after upper blepharoplasty.  Fortunately in most cases the appearance of the eyelids can be significantly  improved.  Seek out an expert plastic surgeon with lots of experience correcting this type of issue.  After a thorough in person evaluation, the actual reason for this look can be determined.  In some patients surgical lowering of the crease is indicated, in some patients judicious use of fillers of fat graft can camouflage excess removal of skin and fat. 

Kimberly,Including photos would be very helpful in allowing us to understand better your concerns.Sometimes after surgery it can be shocking to see a different version of ourselves. I'd suggest you seek independent evaluations from those who know and love you. If they don't see a problem, then you might consider giving yourself time to adjust.If they also see a problem, then I suggest you return to your surgeon for an evaluation.Some options could include, fillers or fat placement around the eye.I hope this was helpful and best of luck.

You may consider either filler or fat injection in the hollow upper eyelids/brows to give more youthful appearance. See the following link.