I can see why you are displeased with the result: the scarring, the nipples point down and out, and you seem to have a "double-bubble" on the right. Let's look at them one at a time.Surgeons take too much credit for good scars and too much blame for bad scars. The redness and thickness of your scars is typical for someone your age 8 months after surgery. Truthfully, there is nothing a surgeon can do to prevent that from happening nor could a surgeon even inflict thick and red scars upon a patient even if they were so inclined. With time they will soften and fade. When a patient with scars like yours after a donut lift insinuates to their surgeon that he or she did something wrong, that patient demonstrates a level of immaturity that makes productive discussion difficult. That redness is a variant of normal, and 100% under biological factors in your own body no one can control.Your chest wall and breasts naturally have a down and out sort of a direction. That can never be remedied with a donut lift, but any more aggressive of a lift would entail a greater degree of scars. Again, that is simply something for which the surgeon cannot be blamed. Look at your favorite after photos. Did the preoperative shape of those patients look like yours? And are you looking at afters of people who had a donut lift with their augmentation or just augmentation? One important thing: you only sent your after images, not your before. Plastic surgery can only be judged by the degree of improvement of that patient, not a comparison of a final outcome with a particular photo or a hypothetical aesthetic ideal. Do you look better now? Do you see in your preoperative photos any characteristics that predict some of the shape issues that bother you now? I bet so.Presumably you vetted your surgeon before your first operation. I don't see anything that justifies losing trust. Give him or her a chance, but you have to approach this maturely, which means a clear recognition of your preoperative configuration and that he or she cannot control the way you heal. Surgery is not magical, and if you do not accept the limitations on what can be achieved for you, then you will frustrate yourself and not put yourself on a path to improving.Your insurance almost certainly only covers postoperative complications such as bleeding and infection, which fortunately you do not have. I've never heard of one of those policies that covered someone without a complication just wanting a better outcome.Give your surgeon a chance. Best of luck to you.