I would like some advice on whether or not to get my breast implants removed.

If this were the first capsular contracture, total capsulectomy with implant exchange would be reasonable.  In recurrent capsular contracture, dermal matrices may be incorporated into the surgery to decrease recurrence.   However, your risk recurrence is higher than the risk of getting a contracture in the first place.  Kenneth Hughes, MD, Board Certified Plastic SurgeonLos Angeles, CA

Recurrent capsular contracture can be difficult to treat. After several failed surgeries, I would consider removal of the implants and possible fat grafting. Some doctors recommend Singulair to treat CC but I have no experience with this drug. 

It's hard to say when enough is enough when one gets recurrent capsular contracture.  Taking the implants and scar tissue out is the only way to guarantee that it won't happen again.  The problem is that your skin may be stretched out to the point that no implants will look bad.  Need to discuss the possiblity with your surgeon and maybe even get a second opinion so that you will be confident in your decision.
Good luck,
Dr. T

I'm sorry you are experiencing this situation.  Since it seems to be a continuing problem, it is likely that it will happen again if you choose to have it treated.  You may want to consider another option such as fat grafting.  It does not provide an identical look to implants, but may be an alternative if you still want more volume than you have naturally.

Recurrent capsular contracture can be very challenging, for both the patient and the surgeon! Going back in and doing the same thing and hoping for a different outcome is unrealistic. Getting a second opinion in your area from an experienced breast surgeon may be a good option. Good luck!