I was trained in only closed Rhinoplasties, but through conferences, courses, journals and watching Videos trained myself in Open Rhinoplasties as well.Your nose could be improved with a Closed (endo-nasal) Rhinoplasty, but I have more predictability of control with tip surgery using an Open rhinoplasty.- And there's no down-side to Open Rhinoplasty - the scar is almost never a problem.There is no more swelling with it, and the slight tip numbness that occasionally occurs will settle, and doesn't bother patients.
The approach used by the surgeon is a function of what he is most comfortable using and not the specific problem encountered. So go on some complimentary consultations with experts and compare recommendations after a full examination and discussion of desired results and look at photos of similar patients and become fully informed about the desired procedure Dr Corbin