In the normal population, if the eyelids are one to two millimeters from each other, it doesn’t draw attention and is considered normal. After reviewing your photos with your eyes open, it appears that the objective of making the eyelid elevated and getting relative symmetry, shape and contour appears to be achieved. When we measure a successful ptosis surgery, we measure the height, contour, aesthetics and symmetry of the eyelids. It obvious with your eyes looking down that there is a difference with your eyes closed but with your eyes open, it appears that you achieved your objective and I know that anyone who looks at your eyes would probably agree that the eyelid height relative to the pupil is where you wanted it to be after ptosis surgery. I think that it is best that you continue communicating with your doctor who did the original surgery. If you’re concerned about extra skin, your original surgeon knows whether or not that’s the case. Sometimes the folds, variability and the appearance is not a function of excess skin but rather the skin being attached or folding in a certain way. An example is like a non-incisional Asian eyelid surgery where it may appear to have overlapping skin when actually there is no extra skin, but the skin is attached in a way so that the eyelid crease can form. A variation of this procedure is done for ptosis surgery when it is appropriate. So my first piece of advice is that you continue communicating with your original oculofacial plastic surgeon. This is the doctor who knows your eye very well and I’m sure has reasons for doing the procedure the way it was done. In choosing revision procedures, you may want to consider some procedures just to improve the scar quality. In our practice, we use a material called platelet-rich plasma which is drawn from your own blood to help scars that are very thick. We have also found this to be very helpful in softening scars. There was no clear indication from your question as to the time frame of where you are in the healing process. When we think of eyelid healing whether it’s skin or muscle to take up to 6 months to a year, not just a few months. Especially in eyelid surgery, an undesirable scar can change over the course of a year so you may want to do some conservative options until considering another surgery. Again, my advice is to meet with the original doctor and discuss your options. If you don’t feel confident about the recommendations then you can consider second opinions. I hope that was helpful, I wish you the best of luck, and thank you for your question.