After resetting should your nose look the same as before?

At this point, it is too early to say. There may be some residual swelling, the nose may have refractured, or may still be misaligned. It is too early to say. I would recommend following up with your doctor for close followup. Good luck. Best, Dr H 

 Trauma to the nose can cause a displaced, or non-displaced nasal fracture. Only displaced fractures are treated. Treatment for a nasal fracture usually is performed with either closed or open reduction of nasal fracture. An open reduction of nasal fracture with osteotomies usually works much better than a simple closed reduction. For many examples of straightening a crooked nose, please see the video and  the link below

A crooked nose that persists after resetting the nose or closed nasal reduction may still have some deviation to it. A deviated nose or crooked nose may require rhinoplasty and septoplasty surgery to align the nasal pyramid with the middle vault and lower cartilages. A consultation with a facial plastic surgeon is recommended.