Does IPL machine brand matter for effectiveness?

Question

I just went to a consult for a few laser treatments on my face, and the derm I saw insisted the type of machine makes a huge difference (she said Lumenis is the best). I got IPL previously with a Palomar Starlux, so wondering if my treatment maybe wasn't as effective as it could have been with Lumenis..?

Andrew T. Lyos, MD, FACS · Answer

Hello and thank you for your question.  There is some validity to what you have been told.  But the most important concern when looking for a provider to treat you face with the IPL is one that is Certified and has experience with this type of technique.  Some lasers may only treat specific skin types, yielding a less effective result.  However, with a board certified professional, you can be most assured they will give you the best treatment possible.  I would recommend a consultation with a provider that can show you their personal before and after photos with the results from their personal work.  I hope this information helps you and best of luck!

Jason Emer, MD · Answer

what matters most with IPL and some others lasers is who is doing it.  the manufacturers are all pretty similar.  personally i like fraxel much better for browns because it helps with wrinkles too.  reds are best treated with vascular lasers like yellow laser or excel v.  Best, Dr. Emer.

Alex Eshaghian, MD, PhD · Answer

Thank you for your question abrinkworth. I understand your concern.
IPL is a great treatment for facial rejuvenation. I tell my patients that it is more important to find a good doctor than a good laser. This is because a good doctor can get great results with any device. Look for experience, before and after photographs, and testimonials. Please consult with a doctor for specific recommendations. Good luck!

Reza Tirgari, MD · Answer

The short answer is: Yes.  There is a big difference between IPL technology.  However there are two factors to consider:
1- is the concern you have best treated with IPL?  Or are there are potential technologies that could treat your issue more effectively?  This is especially true for conditions such as melasma, spider veins, etc.
2- does the practitioner know how to manage the full capabilities of the IPL machine?  It is not uncommon for clients to be either under- or over-treated, sometimes with bad results.
Make sure you have a consultation with a qualified physician who can provide you with the best recommendation.

Shelby Bentz, MD (retired) · Answer

Hello! The answer to your question is Yes, different IPL machines have different strengths, different capabilities and different filters to address different areas of concern.  It also depends greatly on the operator and their proficiency and experience.  I have a Sciton BBL, a very powerful form of IPL.  In the wrong hands, a powerful IPL can result in burns or post inflammatory hyperpigmentation OR very little effect, if the operator is unaware of how to treat different skin types or is inexperienced.  In California, for example, the operator of an IPL or laser must be a physician or RN but there is no mandatory number of training hours.  In Arizona, operators may be estheticians, RNs or MDs, but all must have a certain level of training. I would recommend that asking for both the type of machine and the experience of the person operating it would give you the best outcome.  Best of luck to you.

Does IPL machine brand matter for effectiveness?

Answers (5)

More IPL Questions

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS

Answers (5)

More IPL Questions

Is IPL (ellipse) a good alternative for red post-acne marks? (photos)

IPL 3 days ago. Still have major swelling under eyes. Is this normal?

Did IPL worsen the capillary for good or will this shrink? (photo)

Using Philips Lumea for IPL hair removal and experienced red/brownish spots and blemishes on my leg, advice? (photo)

WE SEND PRETTY EMAILS

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS