Judging by your pictures, it looks like you would be an absolutely great candidate for a breast reduction. The shape, appearance and projection of a breast after a reduction are a combination of technique and a patient’s overall anatomy. The most common reasons breasts look boxy after a reduction, in my opinion, are a lack of tissue rearrangement, a lack of respect for the natural aesthetics of the breasts, and a lack of tailor-tacking (temporarily closing the skin and tissue to ensure you are happy with the results before you suture the skin). Think of a reduction in 2 dimensions--the outer skin and the inner tissue. In order to provide shape and projection to the breast, you must rearrange the breast tissue beneath the skin in a way that can withstand the gravitational effects over time. The tried and true pedicle for a breast reduction is an inferior pedicle. While this can be a great option, the pedicle must be shaped and tacked into proper positioning prior to skin closure to avoid a flat, floppy appearance that will sag over time. There are also alternative pedicles that aren’t as subject to gravity over time and, depending on the patient's anatomy, may be a better option to choose. An ideal breast has fullness medially (think cleavage) and has a great, rounded shape laterally. When removing tissue in a breast reduction, you want your surgeon to preserve tissue medially (to keep that fullness) and take extra time to shape the breasts laterally. I prefer to use liposuction to shape the outer aspect of the breast as I feel it gives me the best control over shape. I also prefer to use liposuction to remove the armpit fat that most women have. Regardless of how your surgeon does it, you want to look for a surgeon who is meticulous about these fine details. Lastly, assessing the shape of the breasts with the patient laying down but also while sitting up is key. We all know natural breasts have a dramatic difference in shape when gravity takes hold. I think the best results come when those markings are considered only ‘preliminary.’ I prefer to first remove excess breast tissue until I have reached the overall desired volume, and then sit the patient up to assess for optimal symmetry and contour before determining the final markings.