Areola "purse string" lift or NO? See my pics and let me know if this PS is making a mistake on me. (photos)

I went to a PS today and he told me I don't need a full vertical lift. He said I'm small enough to do the purse string lift with silicone in front of the muscle. I told him I want it submuscular and he said ok it may not be as perky. Now I'm nervous Bc 2 other bcps told me I need the full lift inverted T plus doctors on here. I'm going to show the drawing he did on me, 2 pics of me, and two procedures he did on other people just like he wants to do on me. Please help am I making a mistake?