Septal cartilage is preferred.
Ear and septal cartilage are actually two different types of cartilage (elastic and hyaline, respectively) and have different mechanical properties. While any cartilage graft can warp (twist or deform over time), septal cartilage tends to be more useful structurally. You're also correct that most surgeon's--myself included--will use septal cartilage over ear cartilage, if it's available. Most patients undergoing their first (and hopefully last) rhinoplasty will have adequate septal cartilage available.
I'd be a bit suspicious of someone advocating ear cartilage first (unless the septal cartilage was too deformed, or had a large perforation). It makes me wonder if the surgeon is experienced at operating on the septum. And if he/she isn't, then that surgeon shouldn't be touching the rest of the nose!
All the best,
For starters, this "warp" has nothing to do with Star Trek and space travel at the multiples of speed of light.
Warped simply means twisted, bent or twisted or deviated.
When we need to lift a heavy nasal tip and keep it up, its support must be sturdy. If the cartilage strut support bends/warps/twists, so will the nasal tip it supports. (Think the Tower of Pisa...)
Cartilage from the septum is sturdier, thicker and straighter than ear cartilage and, unless your septum had already been operated on in a major way (NOT YOU, is still there. It definitely would be a better choice.
Septal Cartilage Grafts used during Rhinoplasty Surgery work well to support and elevate your tip.
If you've never had a previous rhinoplasty, I'm not sure why your surgeon is suggesting the use of ear cartilage. Septal cartilage is stronger, straighter, easier to harvest, and won't leave a scar on your ear.
If your surgeon is experienced, you'll get a good answer. If not, please get a second opinion.
I've attached a link to my rhinoplasty photos for your perusal. Just about all of my Rhinoplasty patients have septal cartilage grafts (Columella-struts), since they work well in helping to support and rotate your tip.
I hope this is helpful, and best regards.
Rhinoplasty and Ear Cartilage
"Warping of cartilage" means that the cartilage can twist out of shape over time. If ear or rib cartilage is not used correctly, there is a higher chance of warping.
In primary rhinoplasty, the choice of cartilage graft is septal cartilage. Septal cartilage is especially good for tip refinement. Ear cartilage is usually reserved for revision rhinoplasty.
Harvesting septal cartilage may not be familiar territory for all surgeons, therefore the choice of ear cartilage.
Best of Luck,
Ear cartilage is higly specialized, thin deformable cartilage that is used all the time for nasal surgery, mainly in reconstruction, and primarily in areas where fine-tuning needs to be performed. Warping occurs as the scars heal and contract over time...these forces can uncontrollably deform the cartilage and twist the results.
I am a big fan of ear cartilage in very specific circumstances or when other sources are not readily available, i.e. septal cartilage from inside the nose. Septal cartilage is very rigid and resists deformation over time better than ear cartilage. Again, both are great options in very specific indications. For tip elevation and a tip-plasty, I typically use septal cartilage if it is available. If it is not and we need structurally rigid support, I then move to rib cartilage.
Make sure you excert all your options and see as many Board Certified surgeons as you can to gather as much information as you can with regard to your particular case.
I hope this helps!
The best source of cartilage for nasal grafts is the septum, if available. Warping is the change of shape of cartilage after the graft is placed. Although it is possible with ear or rib grafts, this is very,very rare.
Rhinoplasty tip surgery and grafts
Ear cartilage can be used for rhinoplasty surgery. It tends to be more flexible and therefore give less support than septal cartilage. For that reason, septum is my personal preference for refining the tip. "Warp" refers to the tendency of some cartilages, including ear cartilage, to bend with time and lose their shape. It's hard to predict the actual chance that this might happen given individual variation. Septal cartilage does not have this tendency. You may want to ask your surgeon if there is some reason for not using septum in your case. Good luck, /nsn.
Septal cartilage better to provide structure
Ear cartilage, which is thinner than septal cartilage, will warp. For smaller more delicate uses ear cartilage can be ideal. For more structural uses septal cartilage tends to be better.
"Warping" can occur with any cartilage. Why not use the septum?
You have asked some interesting questions. "Warping" is when the cartilage implant bends, or changes shape. This may happen to cartilage implants, but is not usually a problem with the strut you have described.
Ear cartilage is not very straight to begin with--so it's not my first choice for a tip strut. I prefer to use septal cartilage--which is generally much straighter. You mentioned that you had never had a rhinoplasty--but have you had a septoplasty--was cartilage removed from your septum? If so, this may be why the surgeon wants to use ear cartilage. If not, ask if the surgeon can use your septum as the donor for the cartilage.
Cartilage warping after rhinoplasty
Cartilage warping after rhinoplasty can occur and may not even be visible until many years after the procedure. The absolute best cartilage for rhinoplasty surgery is your own septal cartilage if it is available. Septal cartilage rarely if ever warps and is always in my opinion the best and should be the first choice. Now if you have had septal surgery before that cartilage may not be available; however, if you have not I would recommend that cartilage be the first choice. You should discuss with your surgeon why he does not wish to use septal cartilage and especially if the purpose is to lift your tip since septal cartilage is inherently straighter, longer, stronger and generally does not warp. I hope this information helps.