Need revision for white scars 1 1/2 years after blepharoplasty (Photo)

Your surgeon removed your upper eyelid fold, a natural part of the facial appearance.  The scar is visible because it is no longer hidden by the upper eyelid fold.  The upper eyelid is droopy due to damage from the surgery which causes the tendon that raises the upper eyelid to be displaced.  It is possible to lower the upper eyelid crease and reconstruct the upper eyelid fold.  It is improbable that your surgeon knows how to accomplish this type of repair.  Simply having him "revise" the scar is not worth your while because this will not hide the scar.  What he is telling you makes no sense.

You have red and blue skin tones in your eyelids, I think that will make it difficult to achieve a significantly better scar.  Good luck, Jane

Some people depigment when they scar, so just taking out the scar may result in a new white scar.  If the wound is too tight and opens a little while healing that can also lead to a white scar.  If you have sufficient skin to actually do a revision, moving the crease down would help to make the scar less visible.