Thick Skin - Limitations for Revision Rhinoplasty?

Without seeing your profile views it is difficult to make an accurate assessment.  Thicker skin does limit how sculpted a nose can become but symmetry should be no more difficult (in fact easier) than in thinner skins

Yes, the thickness of your skin has an important impact on the surgical outcome. If your skin is very thin, then every little detail, good or bad, is apparent as the skin can't mask the changes to the underlying structure. So on one hand, there can be excellent definition, but on the other hand, every irregularity is seen. With thicker skin the structural changes underneath can't be well appreciated. Also the thick skin can't redrape well and if the nose has been reduced too much, the skin remains arched over the underlying cartilage causing a poor result.  

The benefits of thick skin are that it wrinkles less and it hides minor imperfections of the structures under the skin.  In rhinoplasty in thick skinned individuals, the surgeon's challenge is to be certain that detailed structural work is visible.  All desired results can be obtained with more exaggerated changes to the underlying structure  of the nose.  For example, implants may be necessary to achieve definition.  As for whether you should allow the same surgeon to reoperate?  Since chosing the right surgeon is everything, make sure you can see 'before' and 'after' photos or meet others with problems simliar to yours.  This way you can be certain that the desired aesthetic result will be to your liking.  If not, choose another surgeon!