What are my choices after other eyelid looks droopy after ptosis was repaired on one eye? (Photos)

You have some ptosis of the right eye.  When you lift one side, the other one may droop over time due to the Herring's Law.  If the lid height hasn't changed on that side, then you had a slight ptosis before.  If you like the more open side then you should consider doing a surgery on the lower lid to make them even.     

Eyelid asymmetry is very much in the eye of the beholder - based on my review of your photographs, it seems that your left side was over-corrected and that your right upper eyelid position is actually normal. I would suggest lowering the left upper eyelid - however, if you feel strongly that the left upper eyelid position is the position you favor, then the only option would be to raise the right upper eyelid.