Would I be a good candidate for eyelid surgery or should I consider a brow lift? Concerned about drooping (photos)

Your photos indicate you are a good candidate for an upper blepharoplasty. This will remove excess skin from the upper lids, improving the "hooded" look. See a board certified plastic surgeon near you to learn more. I've included a video on this topic that I hope you find helpful.

Good Afternoon! It really depends on your goals and age. A brow lift is a procedure which can work well for many patients. The scarring can be an issue for some - especially if you're younger. Upper eyelids is not uncommon to address in patients in their 30s for improvement. This procedure is easier in my opinion and the results can be quite nice with minimal downtime. I would suggest doing the least invasive option before moving forward with something more aggressive. Hope this helps!