Solid rib graft or DCF and which one would last longer? (Photo)

As you have noted, Asian rhinoplasty using tissue from your own body (autologous grafts) will provide the safest and most permanent results. For dorsal augmentation, a well-executed DCF graft will provide more natural appearing contours without the risk of warping of an en bloc cartilage rib graft. #drdonyoo

It doesn’t look like you are a good candidate for a dorsal graft at all. Each option has its pros snd cons. The DCF is more popular these days and is easier to shape

Thank you for you question. This is a highly-technical question and the correct answer is that they are both equally-effective when applied in the right setting. There are many anatomic variables that contribute to the decision on which technique is best for your nose. It is ok to ask your surgeon for the rationale for their recommendation - in fact, this should be expected. Once you get the information, I would go with whatever answer you feel more comfortable with.

In experienced hands, the rates of warpage for cartilage grafts and resorption for DCF are small enough that they are both considered solid choices in Asian Rhinoplasty.

Best of Luck!

Dr. E