Best Procedure to Correct my Slightly Scleral Show? (photo)

NONE is the best option in your case. Seems like an issue of unrealistic expectations. and no understanding of the risks involved. 

Thank you for your question and photo.  There have been several interesting posts already, so I won't repeat what has already been said.  It’s always difficult to evaluate a two-dimensional photo unless the views are standardized (which is difficult to accomplish without training).  The one thing that immediately strikes me is that the photo appears to have been taken with a camera angle from above, with you looking slightly upward.  The reflection of the camera flash is only a couple millimeters from your upper lid and your lateral and medial limbi (sides of the circles formed by your iris or colored portion of your eye) are nearly touching your upper lid.  Taking that into consideration, it seems unlikely that you need any corrective surgery. But, I would advise you to see a board-certified cosmetic surgeon who can take photos with standardized views and evaluate you in person.  Best of luck.

First, I would recommend no surgery. Your eyes look fine. If you insist on doing something, then, removing a small triangle of your lower lid and pulling the lid tighter should correct what you are seeing.