Hi MILL;
Unless your surgeon is your father or uncle, it is not likely that you are going to have a "free" operation. If you broke your nose, you certainly need to have it fixed, and the most important chore you have now is to find a surgeon who is very experienced and can deliver satisfaction to you.
I am not sure what you mean by "free nose job." Perhaps you are referring to a third partying paying, such as an insurance company. Without more information, I cannot really answer your question. With respect to his "shaving down parts of my nose I dislike," if that is what you want, and the surgeon thinks it can be done, go for it. However, remember that if the broken nose occurred recently, some of the tissues are somewhat eggshell-like and are not appropriate for all elements of surgery. When you consult with a doctor, you will have to ask about the timeline. Now may not be the time to do all that you wish done. The doctor will have to evaluate your breathing. He will have to evaluate how much of the tissue has been broken and misplaced, and what should or should not be done currently, or what can be deferred until a later time.
These are not simple decisions. Therefore, I suggest you do your homework well and be sure to consult with cosmetic plastic surgeons who are very experienced in nasal surgery and who can, therefore, be more likely to satisfy you. Sometimes, under the best of circumstances, it takes a second "touch up" operation to give an ideal result after a nose has been severely injured.
Robert Kotler, MD, FACS
Facial Plastic Surgeon
Author, SECRETS OF A BEVERLY HILLS COSMETIC SURGEON
Author, THE ESSENTIAL COSMETIC SURGERY COMPANION