-Your photos appear to show that although the piercings were closed, the redundant skin that you have from ear lobe stretching/gauging was not removed.
-Closing gauged ear lobe piercings is technically more challenging than closing simple piercings that were not stretched. With ear lobes such as yours, tissue in both the horizontal and vertical vectors needs to be removed in order to avoid misshapen earlobes.
-Definitely meet with a board certified plastic surgeon who can discuss revisional surgery with you. The good news for you is that your ear lobes can still be fixed, but unfortunately this will require another procedure.
-Thanks for sharing your photos!